Rent, then decide for yourself. It's what smart gamers do to save money.
My quicky review as follows written back in October (copied):
It was alright, not even close to a masterpiece like KotOR but interesting still. The story was good, intertwined nicely with Ep. III and IV, the combat was very free but becomes dull after awhile...the combos and such weren't intergrated well enough, too much button mashing, keep it simple. Overall I liked the character though and I really thought I wouldn't after seeing reviews and such, Starkiller's a compellingly human character and wouldn't mind seeing more of him.
Interesting note: Starkiller was originally the name of Luke Skywalkers character in the first draft of the SW scripts.
i agree, was ok overall. was pretty sweet for the first couple levels but wore off after that. very disappointed about the story. no where near as freakin awesome as KOTOR was and still is.